Twi-hards and Pott-heads.

Luna Lovegood:  Half-Blood Prince Poster

With the movie of Eclipse fresh out of the oven, the time again comes when any level-headed, perfectly rational, life-treasuring human being pulls the covers over their eyes and hides from the rabid fans.  Or perhaps I’m a bit unfair.   You see, there are three kinds of Twilight fans.  Type One: Rabid, insane people who stalk Robert Pattinson and ask him to bite their children. These are the ones that call themselves “Twi-hard”.  Type Two: Those who argue for hours and hours over who’s better:  Jacob or Edward.  They will occasionally stop talking to their friends over the issue, but only for a few days, and not forever (for those who hate those of the opposite team forever and always, see “Type One”.)  Type Three: Those who read the books, appreciate them, go to the midnight premieres most of the time, and keep up with the news.  Certain types are, naturally, a little easier to abide by.  For me, I know only Twos and Threes.  I get to read about Ones in the newspaper and online, though.

What makes these young adult book series’ such a phenomenon?  Is it just because they are what they are:  book series’ for young adults whose hormones aren’t stable and therefore it’s not about the books- it’s about the hotness-scale of the characters?  Is it because the writing is the most brilliant thing this side of Mars?  Or is it all about telling a good story?  I think it’s a mixture of all three (of course, many Twilight fans will tell you it’s all about Edward).

I am biased:  I picked up Twilight once when I was a senior in high school and didn’t like the writing style, so I put it back down.  There are a lot of people who have done the same as me, but there are also those who can (and will) argue that Stephanie Meyer’s writing style is easy to read and superior to any other they know.  Hey, awesome.  I’m glad that it works for y’all.

I choose not to talk about my opinions of the characters, or Meyer’s plot (which seems entirely dependent on Bella procrastinating on picking either Edward or Jacob).  I’m not suicidal, see, so I will leave the story itself alone.  From what I have heard, however, the screenplay is fantastically close to the actual books (the Harry Potter directors could stand to learn something) and that is a nice relief to the fans.  However, the film cast and crew probably doesn’t want to be killed by rabid fans by being incompetent.

Is it worth our time and effort to throw ourselves into these fictional worlds?  I’m not just talking about the world of Twilight– goodness knows I’ve been waiting for my letter to Hogwarts for ten years, and there are many out there that would die for a chance to see Hobbiton or have tried to build their own lightsaber.  The real question isn’t whether it’s worth our time and effort, the real question is:  why do we do it?  No series outside of fantasy has as big of a following, as many obsessive fans.

Fantasy has always been escapism.  It is true that young adults seem to pick it up more whole-heartedly (and no wonder- adults obsessing over fictional characters are judged much more heavily than teenagers), but there are people who come home after work and sink into an armchair with that tattered copy of Prisoner of Azkaban that they just finished last night, and they open it up to page one again…  “Harry Potter was a highly unusual boy in many ways…”  It certainly isn’t just the “geek” community who dives into the fandom.  It’s amazing that as everyone is wishing they could fly a tie-fighter instead of punching in data, we are escaping into our fantasy worlds and binding ourselves together as a community.

Oh yes.  I said it.  Twi-hards, you are equal to those wanna-be Jedi.  Pott-heads, you are equal to those who do not simply walk into Mordor.  So even though I do not like Twilight personally, I respect Stephanie Meyer just as much as I respect J.K. Rowling.  They are both gods, in their own right- weaving worlds of wonder for all of us to enjoy.  Whether it is Narnia, or Middle Earth, Tatooine, Forks, Hogwarts, Discworld, the Calla… I can go on.  We all exist in them in our imaginations to escape our world.  Fanfiction is the inner reaches of our souls trying to control those worlds we love.  Roleplaying gives us a chance to live in those worlds, even if only for a moment.

That said, I have a few confessions to make:

  • I dressed up as Obi-Wan Kenobi for Halloween when I was a senior in high school.
  • I own a time turner.
  • I have every single Harry Potter book, including Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, Quiddich Through the Ages, and Tales of Beedle the Bard.
  • I own half of the New Jedi Order series.
  • I have read Attack of the Clones by R.A. Salvatore 5 times.
  • I own the special extended versions of Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone and Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets.
  • I am dressing up as Luna Lovegood (see image above) this Halloween.
  • I have read the Harry Potter series all the way through twice, and I have read Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban at least 10 times (I stopped counting).
  • I have music from A Very Potter Musical on my Zen.
  • I own the Lord of the Rings trivia game… and rock at it.
  • I learned proper English grammar by writing Harry Potter fanfiction.
  • I online-roleplayed in the Potterverse for two years (until there were no more decent forums).
  • I once spent a whole week pouring through my Harry Potter books to prove that Draco and Hermione were a more feasible couple than Draco and Harry, even though I don’t ship Draco/Hermione.
  • I own soundtracks to Lord of the Rings:  Return of the King, Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, and a collectors edition of Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone.
  • I’ve taken the online Harry Potter Sorting Tests enough to know that I don’t fit in one house, I’m split between two (Ravenclaw and Slytherin) but if I was actually at Hogwarts, I’d be sorted into Ravenclaw.
  • I have a toy lightsaber… and nobody else can touch it. *shifty eyes*
  • I own the videogames: Knights of the Old Republic, Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, The Force Unleashed, Lord of the Rings:  The Two Towers, Lord of the Rings:  Return of the King, Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets.
  • I dominate at Harry Potter Scene It.
  • I go to every single Harry Potter premiere I can get to.
  • I went to 2am showings of Attack of the Clones and Revenge of the Sith.
  • I spend the entire time watching the Harry Potter movies pointing out all the discrepancies from the books.  Somehow, this amuses my friends.

That is all I can think of at the moment.  What about y’all – do you have a list of “guilty secrets” that ties you to your favourite fictional worlds?  A cardboard cut-out of Edward Cullen, perhaps?  Arwen’s pendant?  How many times have you walked into your closet, hoping you’d come out in Narnia?  I’d love to know about it!

Advertisements

6 Responses to “Twi-hards and Pott-heads.”


  1. 1 Erin M July 2, 2010 at 3:33 am

    I loved this post! So eloquent; great points. Mmm, escapism ^__^

    Heehee, that’s awesome about your love for HP, LotR, and Star Wars. Best stories I can come up with for them are that my friends and I used to sing the song from “The Mysterious Ticking Noise” (Potter Puppet Pals) all the time, I once wrote part of an LotR fanfic (starring Boromir!), and I put a little braid in my hair like an apprentice Jedi when I went to see Episode III in theatres.

    Hahaha, that was more nerdiness than I needed to share. XD

    Actually, I could probably come up with better examples if I set my mind to it . . .

    Anyway. Like I said. Fab post! =D

    • 2 slytherclawchica July 2, 2010 at 3:52 pm

      😀 Glad you like it! It’s funny, Twilight fans don’t consider themselves “geeks” even though HP, LotR and SW would be considered geeky for obsessing the way they do.

      😀 Everybody I know sings the Mysterious Ticking Noise. It makes me smile. 🙂

  2. 3 Daryl July 3, 2010 at 2:51 am

    Great entry!

    I couldn’t make it through the first Twilight book but I’m in no position, being surrounded by the glass walls of my own fantasy house, to throw stones.

    I first read The Hobbit back in – gods! – about 1970 (yeah, yeah, they did have printing presses back then – honest!). I followed right up with LoTR, and have re-read all of those at least once every two or three years since. I’m too tired to do the math on that one, but y’all are welcome to calculate what that comes out to. (Let me know the answer.)

    I have an awesome audio book edition of The Hobbit, and yes, I have a Ring. And if Peter Jackson doesn’t do The Hobbit properly and before Ian McKellan’s too old to play Gandalf, I will personally track him down and hand him over to Sauron.

    A guilty LoTR secret? I still get tears in my eyes when I start re-reading the books, and in the opening scenes of Jackson’s version of The Fellowship.

    I totally loved the Harry Potter series – books and movies. I have to admit, though, that once I read the final book I lost the craving to re-read them. I hope the urge will come back. They really are too fun to stay away from. I keep watching for my Hogwarts letter to show up, too, but no luck. If it does, I hope Luna Lovegood’s still around there somewhere, ’cause she and Tonks were both wonderful characters. (Tonks got shortchanged all around – in the movies, and at the end of Book 7. I still haven’t forgiven Rowlings for the way she blithely killed Tonks without so much as a final death scene.)

    And even though I wouldn’t want to live in any of Tanith Lee’s worlds that I’ve seen so far, I sure do find myself compelled to visit them whenever possible. I wish that woman a thrice-long life and an endless supply of ink and paper. I suspect I might have a small drop of Scarabae blood in my veins….

    • 4 slytherclawchica July 3, 2010 at 2:04 pm

      I actually disliked the last Harry Potter book because it felt (to me) like “gah, I am so done with this, here, have an ending”. Some parts were incredibly well thought out, but Rowling definitely short-changed her readers in regards to the minor characters. I think Draco definitely deserved redemption… but… I will cut myself off. Because I can keep going and going. But yes, Tonks definitely got short-changed. I was hoping she’d end up a DADA teacher.

      As far as I know, the Hobbit is slated for 2012, Jackson directing alongside someone else. McKellan’s in it, if I recall. Look it up on IMDB. 🙂

      • 5 Daryl July 3, 2010 at 2:48 pm

        Actually, I’d like to hear your thoughts about Draco’s redemption, etc. And what did you think about Snape in the end?

        I didn’t mention Star Wars, but I loved the first three (Episodes IV – VI), thought Episode I was okay, and felt it went downhill from there. I got that same feeling about George Lucas’s explanation of Anakin’s conversion to Darth Vader that you got about the last Potter book: “Okay, dammit, here’s an ending – now quit bugging me!”

        I had read that Jackson’s supposed to be working on The Hobbit (hooray!!!), but then I keep reading about various problems, delays, disagreements with the studio, etc. I have not yet found faith that it will actually happen, but I sure hope it does. So many others have tried, and all of them have fallen. Most seem to treat it like a trite children’s book, which annoys the &$^% out of me.

  3. 6 slytherclawchica July 4, 2010 at 11:38 pm

    Well, after DH, Rowling very much had Draco set up to redeem himself, and his family. He had many opportunities, but always cowarded out. I feel similarly about Snape. There was really no resolution with either of their characters.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




something to think about

"You know, I don't know if you'll understand this or not, but sometimes, even when I'm feeling very low, I'll see some little thing that will somehow renew my faith. Something like that leaf, for instance - clinging to its tree despite wind and storm. You know, that makes me think that courage and tenacity are about the greatest values a man can have. Suddenly my old confidence is back and I know things aren't half as bad as I make them out to be. Suddenly I know that with the strength of his convictions a man can move mountains, and I can proceed with full confidence in the basic goodness of my fellow man. I know that now. I know it." ~ End of Act I in the musical You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown.

competing for the house cup

Like what you read? Click here to get the latest posts sent straight to your email!

Join 6 other followers


%d bloggers like this: